Double Fine shifts Amnesia Fortnight to Kickstarter
IndustryComments
All this talk of marketability ignores the actual labor involved. It is one thing for a crowd to vote for a complex mechanic, but it is another for the developers to scramble to prototype it on a jam schedule.
The claim that this moves the greenlighting process to a public forum is a bit bold. In previous iterations, the studio leadership always held the final veto over which projects actually secured a full production budget.
The details specify that high tier backers get a curator status. This means the community filter is weighted toward those providing the most capital, rather than a pure democratic vote.
A public vote can actually shield the more eccentric prototypes. If a niche concept proves it has a dedicated audience early on, it gives the studio a data backed reason to ignore safer, more generic design choices.